Live Action.

Posted May 20th, 2007 at 04:31am

What do you guys think of animes/mangas that have been made into live action series/movies? Do you wish they'd stuck to the original story or are you satisfied with the different plots? I think that it's weird that other countries use stories from other countries instead of producing it on their own, though I doubt fans care where it's coming from...til they see it anyways. Any thoughts?

You can correct me if I'm wrong but from the information I've read here and there, I think this is about right...

Produced by another country:
Marmalade Boy (Taiwan?)
Devil Beside You (Taiwan?)
Mars (Taiwan?)
Initial D (China/HK?)

Produced by country of origin:
NANA (Japan)
Death Note (Japan)
Goong/Princess Hours (S. Korea)

I originally posted this in the forums here:

http://www.asianave.com/forums/thread.html?thread_id=802

I only got one response so far and well I'll ask here just in case more people will read it lol.

Comments (5)

Add Comment
Comments Options
Sort comments by:




lean_angle

Male, 38, Santa Maria, CA

Posted


I wanted to write my own name in a death note after watching Death Note live action. omg *puke*


MIDnite99

Male, 36, Netherlands

Posted


Well the only live action I liked was GTO/hana yori dango(japanese and taiwanese) which followed the storyline quite accurate. But most of the movies which are made sucks donkey B@LL.
Live actions that sucks:
-Initial D- the cast are Hk/taiwanese/Japanese, they speak canto, the background music sucks, the only good thing were the cars and location. This movie was a huge disappointment as a fan of ID.
-Death Note - well the last poster said enough.
-Cashern - Great trailer, but that's it.

And remakes of asian movies by Hollywood all sucked.
Well that's for now ;)


CLOSED

Male, Age Private, San Jose, CA

Posted


"Oldboy." Wicked. It totally turned my head, and set a new standard for me w/r/t how well a manga title can translate onto film. Park Chan-wook films aren't always easy to watch, but they are insanely good.


interGal...

Male, 36, Alhambra, CA

Posted


Wow, I didn't know Oldboy was from a manga. The Gto conversion from an anime to a movie, was uh, let's just say i didn't like the movie. I just recently watched the live series and it did well, but not as good as the anime. Good actor though...As for the Initial D, saw the movie preview, and I will not watch it.


CLOSED

Male, 31, New York, NY

Posted


hi personally i think they should leave the live action alone or if they do base it off the characteristics of the show then the actual title...as of now there working on dragonball z o thats like the quiet before the storm...atleast try advent children format first i prefer that or make a new series

~albee~



blog archive

get in touch

You must login or register in order to get in touch.